Fighting an eviction in Ontario can be a complex and stressful process, but there are ways to potentially challenge it if you believe it is unjust or if you have a valid reason to remain in the rental property. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to fight an eviction in Ontario:
1. Understand the Reason for the Eviction
• First, carefully review the notice of eviction (also known as a Notice of Termination) from your landlord. This will outline the reason for the eviction, such as:
o Non-payment of rent
o Breach of lease terms (e.g., damage to property, illegal activities)
o The landlord requires the unit for personal use or to renovate
• Understanding the grounds for eviction is critical because it helps you decide how to proceed in fighting the eviction.
2. Review the Legal Requirements
• Make sure the landlord has followed all the legal procedures required under Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act (RTA):
o Proper notice: The landlord must give the proper notice period before seeking eviction. The notice period depends on the reason for eviction (e.g., 14 days for non-payment of rent, 60 days for personal use).
o Eviction process: The landlord cannot simply evict you without going through the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB). They must apply for an eviction order from the LTB and the Board must hear the case before an eviction can take place.
3. Communicate with Your Landlord
• Negotiate: If the eviction is due to non-payment of rent or other issues, try to resolve the problem directly with your landlord.
o You could work out a payment plan for overdue rent or agree to make repairs if that is the cause.
o Open communication may help you avoid eviction or buy time to find another solution.
• Keep any agreements in writing, and make sure both you and your landlord are clear about the terms.
4. File a Response with the Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB)
• If your landlord has applied to the Landlord and Tenant Board for an eviction hearing, you will receive a hearing notice.
• You can respond to this notice and attend the hearing to present your case. You may want to:
o Deny the grounds for eviction (e.g., if the landlord’s claims are false or unjustified).
o Provide evidence of payments you made (for non-payment of rent) or demonstrate that the landlord has not followed the proper legal procedures.
• File a Tenant’s Response with the LTB to formally dispute the eviction if you believe the eviction is unfair or not legally justified.
5. Prepare Your Case for the Hearing
• Gather evidence: To support your case, gather all relevant documents, such as:
o Receipts, bank statements, or proof of rent payment if non-payment is the issue.
o Correspondence with your landlord (emails, letters, text messages).
o Witnesses who can support your side of the story (e.g., neighbours, friends).
o Repair records or photographs if the eviction is due to damage or maintenance issues.
• Review the law: Familiarize yourself with the Residential Tenancies Act and the specific grounds for eviction. It may help to consult legal resources or seek advice from tenant advocacy groups.
• You can also ask for a Legal Aid lawyer or get assistance from a tenant support organization to help with your case.
6. Attend the LTB Hearing
• The LTB hearing is where both you and your landlord will present your case before an adjudicator, who will then decide whether the eviction should proceed.
• Be prepared to explain why the eviction is unjust or illegal. Present all evidence you’ve gathered, and speak clearly about your side of the story.
• You will have the opportunity to cross-examine the landlord or their witnesses, and vice versa.
7. Possible Defenses Against Eviction
• Non-payment of Rent: If the eviction is due to non-payment of rent, you might have a defense if you can prove:
o You have paid the rent or there is a mistake in the landlord’s records.
o You’ve already paid part of the rent and need time to catch up.
o You were not provided with proper notice (e.g., not given 14 days’ notice before the landlord took action).
• Repair and Maintenance Issues: If the eviction is for damage or violation of lease terms, you might argue that the landlord is responsible for maintenance issues or has not provided adequate repairs.
• Improper Notice: If the landlord did not serve the eviction notice in accordance with the legal requirements (e.g., wrong notice period or improper delivery), you can challenge the eviction based on procedural errors.
• Discrimination or Retaliation: If the eviction is based on discriminatory reasons or in retaliation for making a complaint (e.g., about maintenance or harassment), you may be able to fight the eviction. Ontario’s Human Rights Code prohibits eviction for discriminatory reasons.
• Landlord’s Application Was Filed Incorrectly: If the landlord did not properly apply to the LTB or follow the required steps to initiate eviction, you may be able to challenge the process itself.
8. The LTB’s Decision
• After the hearing, the LTB will issue a decision. There are several possible outcomes:
o Dismissal of the eviction: The eviction is canceled if the adjudicator finds the landlord’s case insufficient or flawed.
o Temporary Stay: The adjudicator may delay the eviction to give you more time (e.g., to catch up on rent).
o Eviction Order: If the adjudicator finds in favor of the landlord, they may issue an eviction order, but they will typically give you some time to leave (this is called a stay of eviction).
9. Appealing the Decision
• If you disagree with the LTB’s decision, you can appeal the decision within a specific time frame (usually 30 days). Appeals must be based on legal grounds, such as a mistake in the application of the law.
10. Seek Legal Assistance
• If you’re not sure how to proceed, consider seeking advice from a tenant rights organization or a legal professional who specializes in landlord-tenant law. They can help you navigate the process and build a stronger case.
• Some organizations in Ontario provide free or low-cost legal assistance, including Legal Aid Ontario or tenant advocacy groups.
________________________________________
Key Takeaways:
• Know your rights under the Residential Tenancies Act.
• Communicate with your landlord to resolve issues before they escalate to eviction.
• Respond promptly to any eviction notices or LTB applications.
• Prepare a strong case for the LTB hearing with proper documentation and evidence.
• Seek legal help if necessary to improve your chances of fighting the eviction.
By taking the appropriate steps and understanding the legal process, you can protect your rights and, in some cases, successfully fight an eviction in Ontario. If you or anyone you know are facing a possible eviction, contact Capulli Law LLP – we are always here to help.